Archimedes used to demand just one firm and immovable point in order to shift the entire earth; so I too can hope for great things if I manage to find just one thing, however slight, this is certain and unshakeable. (Med, 16)
At this point in the Second Meditation of Descartes' Meditations on First Philosophy, the meditator finds herself in "a deep whirlpool," (Med, 16) where perhaps the only thing that is certain is that there is no certainty. Having trained herself to consider anything that could admit the slightest doubt as utterly false, the mediator searches for her Archimedean point, an undeniably certain datum that, once found, will act as the balance upon which the certainty of all subsequent knowledge can be measured. Offered informally as the famous cogito reasoning in the Second Mediation, this logical argument is used by Descartes to posit the meditator's knowledge of the existence of "I," or self as a thinking substance, as the unshakeable datum:
- Thought, as an act, inheres in a substance.
- I am thinking.
- Therefore, I exist at least as a thinking substance.
Although this argument is valid, it is not sound in the context of the method of doubt; the first premise presupposes concepts of thought and substance, the veracity of the second premise relies similarly on the preconceived notion of thought, and the second premise depends on, at the very least, the thinnest interpretation of "I" to be found in the conclusion, while also implying the preconceived notion of consciousness.